PROPANDA AD LIES


Claim Stated Odds Reality / Notes
Skiing injury 1 in 334 Recreational skiing injury rates in Canada: ~1 in 446 skier‑days (PubMed 2020, 2.24 injuries per 1,000 skier‑days). Likely exaggerated.
Being pickpocketed 1 in 3,534 No official Canadian national data; urban crime reports suggest much lower risk per day. Likely chosen for rhetorical effect.
“Going under” (death) 1 in 10,386 Canada’s crude death rate ~8–9 per 1,000 per year → ~1 in 111 per year. The ad’s number may reflect annualized low‑risk activity or lifetime probabilities of sudden death. Likely not precise.
Getting shingles 1 in 3 Accurate lifetime risk according to Canadian public health sources.

Observations:

  1. Shingles odds are the only fully credible figure.

  2. The other three odds—skiing injury, pickpocketed, and “going under”—appear rounded or dramatized for advertising contrast.

  3. The ad uses a rhetorical device: comparing rare everyday risks with a common health risk (shingles) to encourage vaccination.

  4. Timeframe mismatch is important: some odds are per day, some per lifetime. The ad ignores this for simplicity.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Dave Mason and is Fascist buddies.

British Police ARREST People For Carrying CASH